NILVault AI

NIL Law Library

Educational reference only — not legal advice. Laws change frequently; verify every citation before reliance and consult qualified counsel for decisions.

All (15)
Case Law (4)
Governance (1)
Statute (4)
Guidance (2)
Executive Order (1)
Bill (1)
Compliance Domain (2)

N.D. Cal. (2026)

House class counsel motion re CSC scope (MMR deals)

Case Law
Pending

Dispute over CSC jurisdiction to review NIL deals involving university multimedia-rights partners; court declined to categorically exclude MMRs — jurisdiction turns on the entity's relationship to the school.

Athletic DepartmentsBrands
Source

Settlement arbitration (2026)

CSC deal-denial arbitrations (first wave)

Case Law
Pending

CSC rejection of $7.5M+ in Nebraska athlete deals produced the first settlement arbitrations; confidential outcomes are becoming the de facto case law of deal review.

AthletesCollectives

Executive Order 14400

Uniform NIL Framework for Federally Funded Institutions

Executive Order
Active

Directs federal agencies to encourage a uniform national NIL compliance framework across states for institutions receiving federal funding.

Athletic DepartmentsHigh Schools

S. 1234 (118th Congress)

Protect College Sports Act

Bill
Proposed

Proposed federal legislation seeking to establish national NIL standards, preempting the current patchwork of state-by-state NIL statutes.

Athletic DepartmentsAthletes

House v. NCAA Settlement

Revenue-sharing cap and back-damages settlement

Governance
Active

Establishes a per-school revenue-sharing cap (initial $20.5M, escalating over the settlement term) and a College Sports Commission (CSC) to review NIL deals for fair-market-value compliance.

Athletic DepartmentsAthletesCollectives

NCAA v. Alston, 594 U.S. 69 (2021)

Antitrust limits on NCAA education-related compensation caps

Case Law
Enacted

Supreme Court held NCAA rules limiting education-related benefits violate antitrust law, paving the legal groundwork that led to broader NIL compensation reform.

Athletic DepartmentsAthletes

O'Bannon v. NCAA, 802 F.3d 1049 (9th Cir. 2015)

Right of publicity foundations for college athletes

Case Law
Enacted

Early foundational case establishing that NCAA amateurism rules restricting athlete compensation for use of their name, image, and likeness are subject to antitrust scrutiny.

Athletes

IRS Guidance — NIL Collective Tax-Exempt Status

IRS memorandum on collective 501(c)(3) eligibility

Guidance
Active

IRS guidance concluding that many NIL collectives do not qualify for tax-exempt status where the private benefit to athletes is not sufficiently incidental to any exempt purpose.

Collectives

State NIL Statute Survey

State-by-state NIL statute variability

Statute
Active

States vary widely — some (e.g. New York, California, Texas) have comprehensive NIL statutes with specific disclosure and agent-registration requirements; several states have no NIL-specific statute at all, defaulting to institutional and NCAA/CSC policy.

Athletic DepartmentsAthletesHigh Schools

NIL Go Disclosure Framework

NCAA NIL Go aggregate disclosure thresholds

Compliance Domain
Active

NCAA's disclosure framework requiring athletes to report NIL deals above defined thresholds for fair-market-value review; includes safe-harbor treatment for deals in the $600-$15,000 range until an athlete's aggregate deals exceed $50,000/year.

Athletic DepartmentsAthletes

Multi-State Income Tax Guidance

Athlete multi-state tax exposure from travel/competition

Guidance
Active

General tax guidance on athletes' obligation to allocate and potentially owe income tax in each state where they compete or earn NIL income, independent of their state of residence ('jock tax' principles applied to NIL income).

Athletes

26 U.S.C. § 1441 — NRA Withholding

Nonresident alien withholding on U.S.-source income

Statute
Active

Federal statute requiring 30% withholding (absent an applicable tax treaty) on U.S.-source income paid to nonresident alien individuals, relevant to international student-athletes earning NIL income.

AthletesAthletic Departments

FERPA, 20 U.S.C. § 1232g

Student education record privacy applied to NIL data

Statute
Enacted

Federal student-privacy statute constraining how universities may share athlete financial and enrollment data tied to education records, informing NIL platform data-isolation design requirements.

Athletic DepartmentsAthletes

Agent Registration Model Act

State athlete-agent registration and designated-representative rules

Statute
Active

Model act (adopted with variations by many states) requiring sports agents to register with the state and comply with designated-representative filing obligations when representing NIL athletes.

Agents

Brand FMV Verification Standard

Fair-market-value standard for brand-athlete NIL deals

Compliance Domain
Active

The CSC's operative standard for reviewing NIL deals: compensation must reflect a valid business purpose and fair-market range, not compensation for athletic performance disguised as endorsement.

BrandsAthletes